Not even a 100 million strong population may
be enough to save the red crabs of Christmas Island from hordes
of alien insects
BY TIM BLAIR
Monday, Apr. 19, 1999
Six months
ago, three film crews waited on Christmas Island's Greta Beach
to document one of nature's wonders: the annual migration of millions
of red crabs from the island's rain forest to the sea, where they
spawn before lumbering back to their inland burrows. The celebrated
migratory mass lures tourists from around the globe and usually
causes "great excitement," says island social worker
Lorraine Johnston. "The sense of awe never goes away."
But the film crews were underwhelmed. Crabs were thinner on the
ground than in previous years; other beaches on the tiny Indian
Ocean island saw similarly low turnouts.
A decline
in the crab population may have several causes, but Dennis O'Dowd,
director of the Centre for Analysis and Management of Biological
Invasions at Monash University in Melbourne, has identified a
particularly potent crab menace: the yellow crazy ant, Anoplolepis
gracilipes, introduced accidentally to Christmas Island by traders
earlier this century. By O'Dowd's conservative estimate, in the
past couple of years perhaps three million of the Australian territory's
100 million red crabs have been killed by the alien ant.
"They
take over crab burrows, kill the crabs, then turn the burrows
into their nests," says O'Dowd, who, with colleagues Peter
Green and Sam Lake, has studied the red crab since 1986. "Once
the crabs have been exposed to the ants, they lose condition and
die. Tip them over and you'll see that their mouth parts are blackened."
The ants also have a withering effect on the rain forest. While
the crabs' feeding activities-- they eat mainly seedlings and
leaf litter--help maintain the rain forest's structure, the ants
destroy it, establishing multi-queen "supercolonies"
which deplete resources for the forest's vines and trees, as well
as threatening native birds, mammals and reptiles. Even the robber
crab--the largest land crab of all, 1 m wide and able to cleave
a coconut in two with its giant claws--is vulnerable to the 4
mm insect.
Exactly why the crazy
ant (its name derives from its frenzied movements) has turned
on the red crab (Gecarcoidea natalis) is a mystery; it's believed
the two species coexisted harmlessly until recently. O'Dowd
now fears that Christmas Island may suffer the same fate as
Bird Island in the Seychelles, where crazy ants were first detected
in 1991. Eight years later, they occupy half the island, threatening
local species of sooty tern and skink.
O'Dowd
is now urging the Australian government to investigate a chemical
ant-killer. The need, he says, is vital. Super colonies now occupy
about 3% of the island's 100-sq.-km rain forest, and can make
inroads on that forest at a rate of 1 m a day. All in all, says
O'Dowd: "This is one bad ant."
The red
crab is as admired as the crazy ant is despised, even by Christmas
Islanders whose homes are invaded every year by scuttling, half-kilogram
crustaceans taking the most direct route to the sea. Children
scoop up newborn crabs in buckets and carry them across busy roads
to make safer their first journey from beach to forest. "The
migration happens in the same way every year," says Johnston.
"It's very humbling. It's a reminder that the island really
belongs to the crabs." At least for as long as they can hold
out against the ants' hostile takeover.
Because of the scarcity of accurate written records, it has
rarely proved possible to trace the impact of the European
colonists on North American woodlands in anything but general
terms. The Allegheny Plateau, however, was colonized very
late, and large stands of white pine and hemlock survived
to the end of the last century. Written records and surveys
in this area make it possible to follow woodland destruction
and the spread of disturbance-tolerant trees and shrubs, like
red maple and black cherry.
G.G. Whitney, "The history and status of the hemlock-hardwood
forests of the Allegheny Plateau," Journal of Ecology,
78, 443-58, June 1990. (Harvard University, Petersham, Mass.)
The impact of grazing animals on the composition of vegetation
has been extensively studied in domestic animals and in some
past species, such as deer and rabbit. In the rain forests
of Christmas Island (Indian Ocean), however, grazing is carried
out by land crabs. These are fastidious creatures, grazing
more intensively on some seedlings than others, and in this
way playing an important part in determining the nature of
the forest vegetation that eventually develops. Excluding
crabs from experimental plots led to the survival of some
species of seedling normally eliminated by crab depredation.
D.J. O'Dowd, P.S. Lake, "Red crabs in rain forest, Christmas
Island: differential herbivory of seedlings," Oikos,
58, 289-92, August 1990. (Monash University, Clayton, Australia)
Recent analyses of the mass of data now available from fossil
pollen in lake sediments have shown that no two species behaved
in quite the same manner during the climatic changes of the
past 12,000 years. Although the geographical ranges of hemlock
and beech, for example, are now very similar in the northeastern
United States, their convergence is only a very recent one.
Some 10,000 years ago their main distribution centers were
distinctly separate. Evidently, we must rethink our concept
of plant communities. What we now see may be no more than
a coincidence of distributions as species independently respond
to the various environmental factors that impinge upon them.
R.W. Graham, E.C. Grimm, "Effects of global climate
change on the patterns of terrestrial biological communities,"
Trends in Ecology and Evolution, 5, 289-92, September 1990.
(Illinois State Museum, Springfield)